The Contrarian with David Bernstein

Orthodoxy and the Academy w/ Prof Suzanna Sherry - S2 Ep 14

Episode Summary

Prof. Suzanna Sherry discusses the evolution of Critical Race Theory and its implications for antisemitism, the resurgence of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, and the impact of social media on academic discourse. She explores the tension between university policies and campus culture regarding free speech, the influence of political climates on academic freedom, and the challenges of maintaining ideological neutrality in education. The conversation emphasizes the need for accountability in academic practices and the importance of fostering a culture of open dialogue in universities. About the Guest Suzanna Sherry is Professor Emerita and former Herman O. Loewenstein Chair in Law at Vanderbilt University Law School. A nationally recognized scholar of constitutional law, federal courts, and judicial decision-making, she has authored over a hundred books, chapters, and articles exploring the role of courts, federalism, and the limits of ideology in the legal system. Before joining Vanderbilt in 2000, she taught at the University of Minnesota Law School and previously practiced law in Washington, D.C., after clerking on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. Known for her rigorous teaching and clear-sighted analysis of the Constitution, Professor Sherry retired from Vanderbilt in 2022 after a distinguished four-decade career shaping legal thought and education

Episode Notes

00:00 The Origins of Critical Race Theory and Antisemitism 

02:58 The Resurgence of Critical Race Theory and DEI 

05:58 The Impact of Social Movements on Racial Discourse 

08:59 The Orthodoxy of DEI and Its Implications 

11:57 The Conflict Between Free Speech and Campus Culture 

14:59 The Role of Political Climate in Academic Freedom 

17:58 The Dangers of Blunt Political Interventions 

20:53 Navigating the Future of University Discourse 

25:32 The Impact of Educational Policies on Racism and History 

28:12 Navigating Free Speech in Universities 

29:08 The Role of Universities in Promoting Free Speech 

31:43 Challenges of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) Initiatives 

34:34 The Complexity of Teaching Civic Values in K-12 Education 

36:22 Institutional Neutrality and Ideological Bias in Education 

39:09 Balancing Free Expression and Academic Freedom 

42:00 Addressing Academic Malpractice and Orthodoxy 

45:51 The Dangers of Imposing Orthodoxy in Antisemitism Education